Abstract
Due to technological advances, an increasing number of infants and children are surviving with multi-organ system dysfunction, and some are reaching end-stage renal disease (ESRD). Many have quite limited life expectancies and may not be eligible for kidney transplantation but families request dialysis as alternative. In developed countries where resources are available there is often uncertainty by the medical team as to what should be done. After encountering several of these scenarios, we developed an ethical decision-making framework for the appropriate choice of conservative care or renal replacement therapy in infants and children with ESRD. The framework is a practical tool to help determine if the burdens of dialysis would outweigh the benefits for a particular patient and family. It is based on the four topics approach of medical considerations, quality-of-life determinants, patient and family preferences and contextual features tailored to pediatric ESRD. In this article we discuss the basis of the criteria, provide a practical framework to guide these difficult conversations, and illustrate use of the framework with a case example. While further research is needed, through this approach we hope to reduce the moral distress of care providers and staff as well as potential conflict with the family in these complex decision-making situations.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Van der Heijden B, van Dijk P, Verrier-Jones K, Jager K, Briggs J (2004) Renal replacement therapy in children: data from 12 registries in Europe. Pediatr Nephrol 19:213–221
Canadian Organ Replacement Register Annual Report (2014) Treatment of end-stage organ failure in Canada, 2003 to 2012. Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI), Toronto. Available at: www.cihi.ca/corr
Goldberg AM, Amaral S, Moudgil A (2014) Developing a framework for evaluating kidney transplantation candidacy in children with multiple comorbidities. Pediatr Nephrol. doi:10.1007/s00467-013-2704-4
Zurowska A, Fischbach M, Watson A, Edefonti A, Stefanidis C, European Paediatric Dialysis Working Group (2013) Clinical practice recommendations for the care of infants with stage 5 chronic kidney disease (CKD5). Pediatr Nephrol 28:1739–1748
Shooter M, Watson A (2000) The ethics of withholding and withdrawing dialysis therapy in infants. Pediatr Nephrol 14:347–351
Renal Physicians Association (RPA) (2010) Shared decision-making in the appropriate initiation of and withdrawal from dialysis: Clinical practice Guideline Recommendation Summary. Second edition. RPA, Rockville.Available at www.renalmd.org
Rees L (2008) Management of the neonate with chronic renal failure. Semin Fetal Neonatal Med 13:181–188
Jonsen A, Siegler M, Winslade W (2010) Clinical ethics: a practical approach to ethical decisions in clinical medicine, 7th edn. McGraw Hill, New York
Moss A (2011) Ethical principles and processes guiding dialysis decision-making. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 6:2313–2317
Kodner IJ (2009) Surgeons and ethics: You bet! J Am Coll Surg 209:1–6
Diekema D, Botkin J (2009) Foregoing medically provided nutrition and hydration in children. Pediatrics 124:813–822
Schaefer F, Warady B (2011) Peritoneal dialysis in children with end-stage renal disease. Nat Rev Nephrol 7:659–669
Paul A, Fraser N, Manoharan S, Williams A, Shenoy M (2011) The challenge of maintaining dialysis lines in the under twos. J Pediatr Urol 7:48–51
Beanes S, Kling K, Fonkalsrud E, Torres M, Salusky I, Quinones-Baldrich W, Atkinson J (2000) Surgical aspects of dialysis in newborns and infants weighing less than ten kilograms. J Pediatr Surg 35:1543–1548
Neu A, Sander A, Borzych-Duzatka D, Watson A, Valles P, Ha I, Patel H, Askenazi D, Batasz-Chmielewska I, Lauronen J, Groothoff J, Feber J, Schaefer F, Warady B, on behalf of the IPPN investigators (2002) Comorbidities in chronic pediatric peritoneal dialysis patients: a report of the international pediatric peritoneal dialysis network. Perit Dial Int 32:410–418
Fauriel I, Moutel G, Moutard M, Montuclard L, Duchange N, Callies I, Francois I, Cochat P, Herve C (2004) Decisions concerning potentially life-sustaining treatments in paediatric nephrology: a multicentre study in french-speaking countries. Nephrol Dial Transplant 19:1252–1257
Benedetti E, Asolati M, Dunn T, Walczak D, Papp P, Bartholomew A, Smith Y, Washington A, Pollak R (1998) Kidney transplantation in recipients with mental retardation: clinical results in a single-center experience. Am J Kidney Dis 31:509–512
Martens M, Jones L, Reiss S (2006) Organ transplantation, organ donation and mental retardation. Pediatr Transplant 10:658–664
Galante N, Dib G, Medina-Pestana J (2010) Severe intellectual disability does not preclude renal transplantation. Nephrol Dial Transplant 25:2753–2757
Aksu N, Yavascan O, Anil M, Deniz Kara O, Bal A, Berna Anil A (2012) Chronic peritoneal dialysis in children with special needs or social disadvantage or both: contraindications are not always contraindications. Perit Dial Int 32:424–430
North American Pediatric Renal Trials and Collaborative Studies (2012) NAPRTCS 2011 annual dialysis report. Available at: www.naprtcs.org
Chavers B, Li S, Collins A, Herzog C (2002) Cardiovascular disease in pediatric chronic dialysis patients. Kidney Int 62:648–653
Parekh R, Carroll C, Wolfe R, Port F (2002) Cardiovascular mortality in children and young adults with end-stage kidney disease. J Pediatr 141:191–197
Laakkonen H, Holtta T, Lonnqvist T, Holmberg C, Ronnholm K (2008) Peritoneal dialysis in children under two years of age. Nephrol Dial Transplant 23:1747–1753
Rees L (2007) Long-term peritoneal dialysis in infants. Perit Dial Int 27:S180–S184
Wood EG, Hand M, Briscoe DM, Donaldson LA, Yiu V, Harley FL, Warady BA, Ellis EN, North American Pediatric Renal Transplant Cooperative Study (2001) Risk factors for mortality in infants and young children on dialysis. Am J Kidney Dis 37:573–579
Amaral S, Hwang W, Fivush B, Neu A, Frankenfield D, Furth S (2008) Serum albumin level and risk for mortality and hospitalization in adolscents on hemodialysis. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 3:759–767
Wong CS, Hingorani S, Gillen DL, Sherrard DJ, Watkins SL, Brandt JR, Ball A, Stehman-Breen CO (2002) Hypoalbuminemia and risk of death in pediatric patients with end-stage renal disease. Kidney Int 61:630–637
Tsai H, Yang L, Chin T, Wang H, Liu C, Wei C, Chang J (2010) Outcome and risk factors for mortality in pediatric peritoneal dialysis. Perit Dial Int 30:233–239
Zaritsky J, Warady B (2011) Peritoneal dialysis in infants and young children. Semin Nephrol 31:213–224
Vidal E, Edefonti A, Murer L, Gianoglio B, Maringhini S, Pecoraro C, Sorino P, Leozappa G, Lavoratti G, Ratsch I, Chimenz R, Verrina E, Italian Registry of Paediatric Chronic Dialysis (2012) Peritoneal dialysis in infants: the experience of the Italian Registry of Paediatric Chronic Dialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 27:388–395
Hijazi R, Abitbol C, Chandar J, Seeherunvong W, Freundlich M, Zilleruelo G (2009) Twenty-five years of infant dialysis: a single center experience. J Pediatr 155:111–117
Feinstein S, Rinat C, Becker-Cohen R, Ben-Sahlom E, Schwartz S, Frishberg Y (2008) The outcome of chronic dialysis in infants and toddlers—advantages and drawbacks of haemodialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 23:1336–1345
Rheault M, Rajpal J, Chavers B, Nevins T (2009) Outcomes of infants <28 days old treated with peritoneal dialysis for end-stage renal failure. Pediatr Nephrol 24:2035–2039
Shroff R, Rees L, Trompeter R, Hutchinson C, Ledermann S (2006) Long-term outcome of chronic dialysis in children. Pediatr Nephrol 21:257–264
American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics (1996) Ethics and the care of critically ill infants and children. Pediatrics 98:149–152
Clark J, Dudzinski D (2011) The false dichotomy: Do “everything” or give up. Am J Bioeth 11:26–27
Clark J, Dudzinski D (2013) The culture of dysthanasia: attempting CPR in terminally ill children. Pediatrics 131:572–580
Carson R (2012) Deny dialysis or “D-NI” dialysis? The case for “do not initiate; do not ignore” orders. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 7:1924–1926
O’Connor N, Kumar P (2012) Conservative management of end-stage renal disease without dialysis: a systematic review. J Palliat Med 15:228–235
Rombola G (2002) Dialysis for everybody? At any cost? J Nephrol 15:S33–42
Lantos J, Warady B (2013) The evolving ethics of infant dialysis. Pediatr Nephrol 28:1043–1947
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dionne, J.M., d’Agincourt-Canning, L. Sustaining life or prolonging dying? Appropriate choice of conservative care for children in end-stage renal disease: an ethical framework. Pediatr Nephrol 30, 1761–1769 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00467-014-2977-2
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00467-014-2977-2