Table 1

Clinical features of patient populations in included studies

#AuthorTotal cases (N)Years includedCountryAGEMale sex %Microbiology (%)Prosthetic valve %Cardiovascular device %INJECTION DRUG USE %Mortality %Required surgery %
1Scudeller 2009182542004–2008ItalyMean: 67.0 (SD 14.0)66.5Enterococci 21.6
S. aureus 17.5
VGS 14.0
32.3NP2.03 months 20.540.2
2Fedeli 20112618632000–2008ItalyMedian 68.0 (IQR: 57.0–77.0)63.0Blood culture data
S. aureus 29.5
CoNS 6.7
Enterococcus faecalis 12.4
Streptococci 28.6
Secondary code data
Streptococci 36.7
S. aureus 17.4
CoNS 6.0
E. faecalis 5.3
6.2NPNPOverall 14.3In-patient 37.0
1 year 38.0
3Thornhill 2011142000–2010EnglandNPNPNPNPNPNPNPNP
4Ternhag 20131676091997–2007SwedenMean 65.7 (IQR: 55–79)59.2NP11.7NP4.730 days—33.7
5 years—14.7
5 years follow-up 13.0
5Dayer 2015219 8042000–2013EnglandMean 59.1
59.0 (SD: 20.3) before 2008, 59.3 (SD 20.8) after 2008
68.5NPNPNPNPNPNP
6Cresti 201611701998–2014ItalyMean 65.7(SD: 16.0)60.9S. aureus 25.0
CoNS 22.0
Streptococcus viridans 15.0
Enterococci 14.0
30.0NP4.01 year 31.8 In-patient 24.01 year 46.5; Urgent/emergent 31.8;
Operated within 10 days 29.0
7Erichsen 20162454861994–2011DenmarkMean: 62.7 (no SD provided)64.4NPNPNPNPNPNP
8Keller 2016394 3642005–2014GermanyNPNPStreptococci 20.8
Staphylococci 21.9
NPNPNPOverall 17.0NP
9van den Brink 20163152132005–2011The NetherlandsMean 67.5 (range: 22.0–97.0)69.9.Staphylococci 36.1
S. aureus 30.1
Streptococci 37.4
30.17.9NPAll-cause 36.1% (Median follow-up 4.2 years)38.9
10Olmos 20171716 8672003–2014SpainMean 63.8 (SD: 17.5)66.3Streptococci 20.4
S. aureus 17.1
Enterococci 13.1
CoNS 12.2
18.01.12.6In-patient 20.423.0
11Ahtela 20181126112005–2014FinlandMean 60.0 (SD: 18.3)68.2NP5.51.5NP30 days 11.3NP
12Jordal 2018127061996–2015NorwayMean 59.2 (need to calculate combined SD)69.1S. aureus 31.1
VGS 23.1
CoNS 11.5
Enterococci 9.5
29.9NP20.730 days 12.7
1 year 21.4
34.1
13Ortega 20192325 9521997–2014SpainOverall mean: 62.2 (18.6)65.9Staphylococci 32.7
S. aureus 19.6
Streptococci 2.5
9.66.5; CIED related IE 21.26.890 days 26.2NP
14Jensen 2020476691997–2017DenmarkMedian 70.2 (IQR: 58.3–78.8)65.2NP15.910.9NPNPNP
15Quan 2020251998–2017EnglandNPNPStreptococci 49.0
Staphylococci 43.0
NPNPNPNPNP
16Shah 20201376381990–2014ScotlandMean 65.0 (SD: 17.0)49.0Staphylococci 42.4
S. aureus 31.7
Streptococci 35.5
Enterococci 8.9
NPNPNP1 year 32.0
30 days 14.7%
30 days 4.8
1 year 10.6
17Thornhill 2020151998–2018EnglandNPNPNPNPNPNPNPNP
18Vähäsarja1046472008–2017SwedenMean 64.9 (range: 17.0–100.0)68.0S. aureus 37.0
VGS 24.7%
NPNPNPNPIn-patient 10.2
  • *The genus and species of the pathogens have been listed as presented in the individual studies. Since the pathogens were grouped differently in each study, it was not possible for us to standardise them.

  • CIED, cardiac implantable electronic device; CoNS, coagulase-negative staphylococci; IE, infective endocarditis; NP, not provided; VGS, viridans group streptococci.