Table 1

Baseline characteristics of the included trials

Trial IDYearCondition(s)Max follow-upNumber randomisedMean age%-Female% on beta-blockers% on calcium channel blockers
Adel2016CAD30 days4557.335.635.6NR
Ageev2010CAD6 mo5063.88.0NRNR
ASSOCIATE2009CAD4 mo88959.915.6NRNR
Barilla2016CAD +HF6 mo5855.432.8NRNR
BEAUTIFUL2008CAD +HF35 mo10 91765.217.186.9NR
Borer2003CAD2 wks360NRNRNRNR
Cay2011CAD30 days120NRNRNRNR
Chen2019CADNR10064.244.0NRNR
CL2-16257-0602009AMI24 hours7559.421.834.9NR
CL2-16257-0962014CAD3 wks1462.914.3100.0NR
CL3-16257-0642010CAD6 wks42759.431.2NR23.1
CL3-16257-0672015CAD36 mo9763.542.273.2NR
CL3-16257-0682012CAD6 wks127760.912.5NR100.0
Di2020CAD3 mo9069.337.8NRNR
Dillinger2015CAD3 wks1263.38.3100.016.7
Gao2017CSA3 mo80NRNRNRNR
Gloekler2014CAD6 mo4664.010.958.717.4
Hao2016CAD3 mo32NRNRNRNR
He2019CAD +HF6 mo6864.847.1NRNR
Hohneck2018CAD6 mo2661.826.973.115.4
Hu2018CAD +HFNR169NRNRNRNR
Huang2018CAD3 mo88NRNRNRNR
Huang (WF)2017CAD3 mo85NRNRNRNR
Kadro2015CAD6 mo50NRNRNRNR
Lamendola2011CAD1 mo2050.075.0NRNR
Naji2014CAD1 mo78NRNR60.3NR
Nguyen2018CAD +HFNR1957.515.894.7NR
RIVENDEL2016CAD2 mo7069.522.958.610.0
RIVIERA2012CAD30 days2761.57.40.00.0
Sallam2016CAD +HF3 mo10063.530.0NRNR
Sayganov2010CAD +HFNR4066.540.0NRNR
Shavarov2015AMI14 days9868.336.7100.0NR
SIGNIFY2014CAD27.8 mo19 10265.027.683.126.8
Steg2013CAD4 mo12459.422.532.3NR
Taccheri2014CAD12 mo90NRNRNRNR
Tagliamonte2019CAD1 mo4166.039.0NRNR
Tatarchenko2008CAD +HF6 mo5957.3NRNRNR
Vasyuk2009CAD6 mo2256.2NRNRNR
Vatinian2015CAD6 mo52NRNRNRNR
Villano2012CAD1 mo31NRNRNRNR
Wang2019CAD +HF6 mo8865.044.3NRNR
Wang2018CAD3 mo80NRNRNRNR
Zhang2018CAD4 mo62NRNRNRNR
Zhang2019CAD +HF2 mo6064.257.0NRNR
Zhang2020CAD +HF6 mo8564.436.5NRNR
Zhao2017CAD3 mo120NRNRNRNR
Zhou2019CAD4 mo9061.442.2NRNR
  • AMI, acute myocardial infarction; ASSOCIATE, Efficay of the I(f) current inhibitor ivabradine in patients with chronic stable angina receiving beta-blocker therapy: a 4-month, randomized, placebo-controlled trial (reference 46); CAD, coronary artery disease; HF, heart failure; mo, months; NR, not reported; RIVENDEL, Heart rate reduction by ivabradine for improvement of endothelial function in patients with coronary artery disease: the RIVENDEL study (reference 41); RIVIERA, Anti-inflammatory effects of ivabradine in patients with acute coronary syndrome: a pilot study (reference 31); wks, weeks.