Table 2

Comparisons of diagnosis of patent foramen ovale between transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) and transoesophageal echocardiography (TOE)

TOE
PFO (+)
TOE
PFO (−)
Total
A
 TTE PFO (+)42547
 TTE PFO (−)58994
 Total4794141
B
 TTE PFO (+)40242
 TTE PFO (−)79299
 Total4794141
C
 TTE PFO (+)35035
 TTE PFO (−)1294106
 Total4794141
  • TOE diagnosis was made by direct visualisation of shunt. TTE diagnosis was made using criteria of cardiac cycles ≤3 and shunt grade ≥I, ≥II or ≥III (A, B and C, respectively).

  • TTE diagnosis: sensitivity=89%, specificity=95%, positive predictive value=89%, negative predictive value=68%.

  • TTE diagnosis: sensitivity=85%, specificity=98%, positive predictive value=95%, negative predictive value=93%.

  • TTE diagnosis: sensitivity=74%, specificity=100%, positive predictive value=100%, negative predictive value=89%.

  • PFO, patent foramen ovale.