Table 1

Selected characteristics of the 33 included trials

CharacteristicNumber (%) or median (range)
Exercise-only CR10 (30)
Setting
 Centre-based14 (43)
 Home-based5 (15)
 Both13 (39)
 Unspecified1 (3)
Sample size52 (19–2331)
Publication date
 1990–19995 (15)
 2000–200922 (66)
 2010 or later6 (18)
Single centre30 (91)
Study location
 Europe20 (60)
 North America*11 (33)
 Other2 (6)
Sex
 Men only12 (36)
 Women only0 (0)
 Both20 (61)
 Unspecified1 (3)
Age (years)60.5 (51–81)
Diagnosis
 HFREF only29 (88)
 HFPEF only0 (0)
 Both4 (12)
Left ventricular ejection fraction (%)29 (21–41)
Included NYHA IV6 (18)
Unspecified4 (12)
  • *HF-ACTION trial also included six French centres (out of 82 centres): +median of study means.

  • CR, cardiac rehabilitation; HFPEF, heart failure with preserved ejection fraction; HFREF, heart failure with reduced ejection fraction; NYHA, New York Heart Association.