Objective While greater body mass index (BMI) is associated with increased risk of developing atrial fibrillation (AF), the impact of BMI on outcomes in newly diagnosed AF is unclear. We examine the influence of BMI on outcomes and whether this is modified by sex and evaluate the effect of non-vitamin K oral anticoagulants (NOACs) in patients with high BMI.
Methods GARFIELD-AF is a prospective registry of 52 057 newly diagnosed AF patients. The study population comprised 40 482 participants: 703 underweight (BMI <18.5 kg/m2), 13 095 normal (BMI=18.5–24.9 kg/m2), 15 043 overweight (BMI=25.0–29.9 kg/m2), 7560 obese (BMI=30.0–34.9 kg/m2) and 4081 extremely obese (BMI ≥35.0 kg/m2). Restricted cubic splines quantified the association of BMI with outcomes. Comparative effectiveness of NOACs and vitamin K antagonists (VKAs) by BMI was performed using propensity score overlap-weighted Cox models.
Results The median age of participants was 71.0 years (Q1; Q3 62.0; 78.0), and 55.6% were male. Those with high BMI were younger, more often had vascular disease, hypertension and diabetes. Within 2-year follow-up, a U-shaped relationship between BMI and all-cause mortality was observed, with BMI of ~30 kg/m2 associated with the lowest risk. The association with new/worsening heart failure was similar. Only low BMI was associated with major bleeding and no association emerged for non-haemorrhagic stroke. BMI was similarly associated with outcomes in men and women. BMI did not impact the lower rate of all-cause mortality of NOACs compared with VKAs.
Conclusions In the GARFIELD-AF registry, underweight and extremely obese AF patients have increased risk of mortality and new/worsening heart failure compared with normal or obese patients.
- Atrial Fibrillation
Data availability statement
All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to copy, redistribute, remix, transform and build upon this work for any purpose, provided the original work is properly cited, a link to the licence is given, and indication of whether changes were made. See: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC
Evidence supports an association between high body mass index and risk of atrial fibrillation (AF). However, the evidence of an association between BMI and AF-related outcomes remains unclear.
WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS
A U-shaped association between BMI and all-cause mortality and heart failure in AF patients is revealed, indicating that underweight or extremely obese patients have a significantly higher risk of mortality and heart failure in comparison with those with normal body weight, overweight or obese patients. BMI, however, does not significantly impact the benefits of non-vitamin K oral anticoagulants (NOACs) versus vitamin K antagonists therapy.
HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY
In clinical practise, BMI should be measured and considered as a risk factor for outcomes in AF. NOACs could be considered for the treatment of all patients regardless of associated BMI.
Atrial fibrillation (AF) is a common arrhythmia associated with significant risk of mortality, cardioembolic stroke and heart failure.1 Evidence supports an association between higher body mass index (BMI) and risk of AF as well as other anthropometric measures including waist circumference, weight and height.2 The association of higher BMI with risk of AF-related outcomes is unclear, with some studies suggesting an inverse relationship.3 4 As obesity is generally considered detrimental to health, this inverse relationship has been described as an ‘obesity paradox’.5 However, this finding has not been consistent.6
Significant sex-based differences exist for both the incidence of AF and the risk of AF-related outcomes.7 Additionally, anthropometric measures differ between men and women.8 In particular, body fat distribution differs substantially.2 9 At present, it is unclear whether the association between anthropometric measures and the risk of AF-related outcomes is similar in men and women.
Given the higher risk of non-haemorrhagic stroke in patients with AF, treatment with oral anticoagulation is often recommended.10 However, concerns have been raised regarding the safety and efficacy of non-vitamin K oral anticoagulants (NOACs) in obese and extremely obese populations.11
This study evaluates a large international cohort of participants with new-onset AF in GARFIELD-AF. The three principal aims were to: (1) assess associations between BMI, weight and height and the risk of AF-associated outcomes; (2) explore sex-based differences in these associations; and (3) examine the association of obesity with the impact of NOAC therapy in patients with AF.
Study design and participants
The GARFIELD-AF design has been previously published (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01090362).12 13 Eligible participants (≥18 years) required a recent diagnosis of new onset non-valvular AF and ≥1 further stroke risk factor. Patients (n=52 057) were enrolled prospectively and consecutively from 35 countries globally into five cohorts from 2010 to 2016, without exclusions according to treatment or comorbidities. Study sites were computationally selected at random from a list of representative care settings. Treatment and therapy decisions were at the discretion of the physician and patient.
Patients <20 years of age, without BMI data or for whom follow-up information was unavailable were omitted from the analysis. Those with a BMI of <15 kg/m2 or >60 kg/m2 were excluded due to likely measurement error in the calculation of height or weight.
Data were collected using electronic case report forms that were securely submitted electronically to the registry-coordinating centre Dendrite Clinical Systems Ltd (Henley-on-Thames, UK). Accuracy and completeness of data was ensured by the coordinating centre, the Thrombosis Research Institute (London, UK). Data were extracted from the study data base on 30 June 2019.
The GARFIELD-AF registry is conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki, local regulatory requirements and International Conference on Harmonization–Good Pharmacoepidemiological and Clinical Practice guidelines.
Patient and public involvement statement
Written informed consent was obtained from all study participants. There was no public or patient involvement in the design or execution of the GARFIELD-AF study design. Investigators from representative investigator sites in each participating country were involved in data collection. Confidentiality and anonymity were maintained through assigned unique identifiers. Independent ethics committee and hospital-based institutional review board approvals were obtained. A full list of ethics committees is provided in the online supplemental material 1.
Patients were categorised into five BMI groups according to the WHO definitions: underweight (<18.5 kg/m2), normal (18.5–24.9 kg/m2), overweight (25.0–29.9 kg/m2), obese (30–34.9 kg/m2) and extremely obese (≥35.0 kg/m2).14
Clinical characteristics and outcomes
Demographic and clinical characteristics were recorded at baseline. The primary clinical outcomes included the rate of mortality, non-haemorrhagic stroke/systemic embolism (SE), major bleeding and new/worsening heart failure according to BMI. These outcomes were also analysed according to BMI and sex. Major bleeding was defined as clinically overt bleeding associated with a critical site, a fall in haemoglobin (≥2 g/dL), transfusion of packed red blood cells (≥2 units), haemorrhagic stroke or fatal outcome.
Continuous variables are reported using medians and IQR. Categorical variables are presented as percentages and frequency counts. Data for the CHA2DS2-VASc and HAS-BLED risk scores were collected; the latter was calculated excluding labileinternational normalized ratios (INRs) as this was not recorded at baseline. Clinical outcomes are described by number of events, event rate per 100 person-years estimated via a Poisson model and 95% CIs. Only the first occurrence of each event was considered. Survival differences across BMI groups were examined using Kaplan-Meier curves.
To identify non-linear association between the continuous variables BMI, weight and height with outcome events, analyses of restricted cubic splines were performed by generating restricted cubic splines with four knots and applying a separate Cox multivariable model for each studied endpoint.
Covariate adjustments for Cox models were selected by avoiding the inclusion of factors in the mediating pathway between BMI and clinical outcomes. Apart from the selected demographic characteristic, smoking status and alcohol consumption were included because of their established relationship with BMI. Chronic kidney disease (CKD) was also considered a possible confounder, as CKD often causes weight loss in later stages.15 16
Three sensitivity analyses were performed; the first analysed the rate of new/worsening heart failure in patients without baseline heart failure. The second examined the association of BMI and AF outcomes in patients with ≥6 months of follow-up. The third adjusted associations for a broader range of covariates.
Comparative effectiveness analyses of NOAC versus VKA were performed in a study population restricted to anticoagulated patients at baseline with a CHA2DS2-VASc score ≥2 (excluding sex) enrolled in GARFIELD-AF cohorts 3–5 (NOACs were not widely available for patients enrolled in earlier cohorts). Analyses were performed for patients with a normal/overweight BMI (18.5–29.9 kg/m2) and separately for those with an obese/extremely obese BMI (≥30 kg/m2). Patients with a BMI <18.5 were not included. HRs for NOAC versus VKA were obtained using a Cox proportional hazards model via a propensity method of overlap weighting to balance covariates in the population. Treatment was defined as the first treatment received at the time of enrolment, approximating ‘intention-to-treat’. Absolute standardised differences for NOAC versus VKA comparison before and after propensity score weighting among normal weight or overweight patients (BMI 18.5–29.9 kg/m2) and obese or extremely obese patients (BMI ≥30 kg/m2) have been presented in online supplemental figure S1a and S1b, respectively.
Only complete cases are presented in descriptive tables. Multiple imputation was applied in the derivation for the modelling process for the estimation of the BMI effect; coefficients and SEs for the risk models were obtained by combining estimates across five imputed datasets. Single imputation was applied for the NOAC versus VKA comparison. P<0.05 were considered statistically significant. Statistical analyses were carried out using SAS (V.9.4).
A total of 40 482 participants were eligible for inclusion within the main analysis: underweight (n=703), normal weight (n=13 095), overweight (15,043), obese (n=7560) and extremely obese (n=4081). The median age of participants was 71.0 years (Q1; Q3: 62.0; 78.0) and slightly over half of the participants were male (n=22 881, 56.5%). Median BMI was 26.9 kg/m2 (Q1; Q3: 24.0; 30.7 kg/m2), and median weight was 75.0 kg (Q1; Q3: 65.0; 88.0 kg). Those with higher BMI were generally younger, more often had diabetes mellitus, hypertension and vascular disease at enrolment and were more likely to have been diagnosed with permanent AF. Baseline demographic characteristics are provided intable 1). Baseline anticoagulation patterns differed significantly among BMI categories; underweight patients were less likely to receive anticoagulation treatment at baseline compared with other groups (60.3% vs 67.9%, p<0.0001, table 1), even when considering only patients at high risk of stroke (ie, CHA2DS2-VASc≥2, 62.1% vs 70.1%, p<0.0001, online supplemental figure S2). Medical history at baseline is provided in table 2.
During a 2-year follow-up, 2805 participants (6.9%) died, 770 (1.9%) suffered a non-haemorrhagic stroke/SE, 730 (1.8%) had a major bleeding event and 589 (1.5%) had a new or worsening heart failure event (online supplemental table S1). Cumulative survival at 6 months, and past 6 month, according to BMI category is shown in figure 1.
BMI association with outcomes
After adjustment, restricted cubic spline regression demonstrated a U-shaped relationship between BMI and all-cause mortality and new/worsening heart failure; both low and high BMI were positively associated with events (figure 2). The lowest risk of all-cause mortality was observed at a BMI of ~30 kg/m2. Below 30 kg/m2, there was a 32% higher risk of mortality per 5 kg/m2 lower BMI (95% CI 25% to 40%). Above 30 kg/m2, there was a 16% higher risk of mortality per 5 kg/m2 higher BMI (95% CI 9% to 23%). The lowest risk of new/worsening heart failure was at ~25 kg/m2. Above 25 kg/m2, each 5 kg/m2 higher BMI was associated with a 23% higher risk (95% CI 14% to 33%). For major bleeding, there was a positive association only in those with low BMI. There was no association between non-haemorrhagic stroke and BMI.
Association of height and weight with outcomes
As with BMI, weight showed similar associations with AF outcomes. A U-shaped relationship was observed between weight and all-cause mortality and new/worsening heart failure, with both low and high weight being positively associated (figure 3). The lowest risk for both outcomes was at ~75 kg. Below 75 kg, there was a 15% higher risk of all-cause mortality per 5 kg lower weight (95% CI 12% to 18%). For every 5 kg higher weight above 75 kg, there was a 1% higher risk of all-cause mortality (95% CI 0% to 3%) and 6% higher risk of new/worsening heart failure (95% CI 3% to 9%). No significant association was observed between weight and the risk of major bleeding or non-haemorrhagic stroke. There was no association between height and AF outcomes (figure 4).
Association between BMI and AF outcomes by sex
BMI showed similar association in both men and women with all-cause mortality; however, there were apparent differences in the strengths of association, p value for interaction assuming a linear trend: 0.01 (figure 5). While higher BMI appeared numerically more strongly associated with all-cause mortality in women (20%, 95% CI 11% to 30% increase per 5 kg/m2 higher BMI above 30 kg/m2) compared with men (11%, 95% CI 0% to 22% increase per 5 kg/m2 higher BMI above 30 kg/m2), the difference in this specific BMI range was not significant (p-interaction 0.32). Conversely, lower BMI (<30 kg/m2) was similarly associated with risk of all-cause mortality in women (15%, 95% CI 7% to 24% increase per 5 kg/m2 lower BMI below 30 kg/m2) and men (16%, 95% CI 8% to 25% decrease per 5 kg/m2 lower BMI below 30 kg/m2 (p-interaction 0.88).
In patients without baseline heart failure, the association between BMI and weight and risk of new heart failure (330 events) was similar (online supplemental figure S3). No association was observed between height and risk of new heart failure. Age did not impact the association between BMI and risk of all-cause mortality or new/worsening heart failure with similar risk of outcomes observed in both younger and older participants (online supplemental figure S4).
Limiting the analysis to participants with at ≥6 months of follow-up (n=39 081) did not affect the association between BMI and AF outcomes (online supplemental figure S5). Furthermore, adjusting for baseline treatment did not alter these results (online supplemental figure S6).
Additional adjustment for a broader range of covariates (model 1: age, sex, ethnicity, smoking status, alcohol use and moderate to severe CKD; model 2: as model 1, plus hypertension, heart failure, diabetes, vascular disease, prior stroke/TIA/SE, history of bleeding and baseline anticoagulation) included suspected mediators of the association between higher BMI and risk of AF outcomes. This led to a substantial attenuation of the association between higher BMI and risk of all-cause mortality (4%, 95% CI −2 to 12% increase per 5 kg/m2 increase). Conversely, there was no meaningful difference in the negative association between low BMI (<30 kg/m2) and all-cause mortality (39%, 95% CI 31% to 47% increase per 5 kg/m2 decrease, online supplemental table S2).
Effects of BMI in relation to NOAC therapy
Participants were separated into two groups: patients with a normal or overweight BMI (BMI 18.5–29.9 kg/m2, VKA participants=5051, NOAC participants=5612) and those with an obese/extremely obese BMI (BMI ≥30.0 kg/m2, VKA participants=2549, NOAC participants=2298). No significant difference was observed in the effect of NOAC therapy between BMI groups (figure 6). NOAC therapy was associated with lower all-cause mortality in both the normal/overweight group (HR 0.77, 95% CI 0.65 to 0.90) and the obese/extremely obese group (HR 0.77, 95% CI 0.60 to 0.99). There were no substantial differences in the impact of NOAC therapy on non-haemorrhagic stroke or major bleeding event risk between BMI groups.
This study demonstrated a non-linear association between BMI and weight, with risk of all-cause mortality and new/worsening heart failure. This suggested that those with both low and high values were at higher risk of these AF outcomes. There was no association of obesity/extreme obesity with the efficacy of NOACs versus VKAs when compared with a normal/overweight group.
Previously, an inverse relationship has been demonstrated between BMI and mortality in AF. Post hoc analysis of 21 028 ENGAGE TIMI-48 trial participants showed a ~10% lower risk of death and stroke per 5 kg/m2 higher BMI.3 Conversely a 6% higher risk of bleeding was demonstrated per 5 kg/m2 higher BMI. Similar findings have been reported from post hoc analysis of AFFIRM (n=2492) and ORBIT-AF participants (n=9513).4 17 Interestingly, results from GARFIELD-VTE similarly supported an ‘obesity paradox’ with all-cause mortality was lowest in obese patients.18 In contrast, Overvad et al6 analysed a subgroup of the Danish Diet, Cancer, and Health cohort and, similar to our results, demonstrated a positive association with higher BMI and, intriguingly, a U-shaped relationship, which was particularly pronounced in women. Our findings support an inverse relationship between BMI and risk of death in AF but only for BMI <~30 kg/m2. Above this level, a strong positive association existed. While not in keeping with most studies examining AF patients, it is consistent with the association between BMI and mortality in the general population.19
The association of BMI with the risk of heart failure in AF has not been well established. Schnabel et al demonstrated a 6% higher risk of heart failure per 1 kg/m2 higher BMI in those with AF (AF cases=725).20 Assessment of the ORBIT-AF cohort, however, revealed no significant association between BMI and risk of heart failure.17 Our results demonstrated that both low and high BMI are associated with risk of new/worsening heart failure. Given the potential for reverse causation, we confirmed this when patients with events in the first 6 months of follow-up were excluded and in those without baseline heart failure.
Reasoning for the difference in our findings compared with prior groups is unclear. This study was limited to new-onset AF. Inclusion of participants previously diagnosed with AF, such as in ORBIT-AF and AFFIRM,4 17 may have led to a selection bias with those dying shortly after diagnosis being excluded. Additionally, previous studies have often adjusted for variables which may mediate relationships between BMI and mortality in patients with AF, such as hypertension/blood pressure, diabetes or history of ischaemic heart disease. Adjustment for variables involved in mediating pathways will necessarily bias results.21 Additional adjustments made in our analysis mitigated the positive association with higher BMI (>30 kg/m2), suggesting that over adjustment may have produced the previously reported negative association between BMI and mortality.
The mechanisms underlying the association between BMI and AF outcomes are not clearly established. Greater BMI has been associated with higher risk of hypertension,22 diabetes23 and coronary heart disease,24 which are established risk factors for mortality and heart failure. However, these comorbidities are associated with risk of ischaemic stroke,25 which was not associated with BMI in our analysis. As such, the mediating pathway between BMI and mortality/heart failure in AF may partially lie outside these established risk factors. Increasing adiposity has been associated with higher levels of epicardial fat and atrial fibrosis both of which are risk factors for AF.26 Further exploration into the role of cardiac factors in the association between BMI and AF outcomes may therefore be warranted.
Trend differences were observed in the BMI association with outcomes between sexes; high BMI was more strongly associated with mortality among women. However, the observed differences were numerically small, and more research is required to identify significant effect modifications between sexes.
Despite a strong association between height and risk of AF, there has been limited assessment of the association of height with AF-related outcomes. Height has previously been shown to be inversely associated with risk of stroke and cardiovascular disease.27 28 However, the association of height with cardioembolic stroke is not clear. A small case–control study in South Korea suggested a possible inverse association between height and stroke in those with AF.29 However, our findings have suggested no association between height and AF-related outcomes. Height is often considered a surrogate marker for lean mass. As such, these results may suggest that fat mass, rather than lean mass, is associated with higher mortality and heart failure in those with AF. This would contrast with AF risk itself where both lean and fat mass are associated.2 Our findings suggest a need for assessment of the association of lean and fat mass with risk of AF outcomes.
The causal relevance of this association between BMI and AF outcomes is not clear. However, previous trials of weight loss in patients with AF have demonstrated substantial improvements in symptoms and AF burden.30 To date, no randomised trial of weight loss in AF has been powered to detect meaningful changes in AF outcomes. Our results suggest that further assessment of weight loss in overweight/obese individuals with AF should be considered to determine the impact on reduced mortality and heart failure.
The potential detrimental effects of raised BMI on the efficacy of NOAC therapy have been raised previously.11 Robust pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamics data in obesity and extreme obesity are lacking. Piran et al31 suggested that one-fifth of extremely obese patients have a peak NOAC plasma concentration below the expected range. A meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials also suggested a similar rate of stroke and major bleeding in obese patients treated NOACs and warfarin.32 In line with this, our findings suggested there is no difference between NOAC and VKA therapy on the risk of non-haemorrhagic stroke or major bleeding in obese/extremely obese participants. In contrast, our results demonstrated substantially lower all-cause mortality with NOAC compared with VKA therapy in both normal/overweight and obese/extremely obese participants. This suggests that while there may be differences in the pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics of NOACs in obese/extremely obese individuals, NOAC therapy is likely more beneficial than VKA therapy in those with higher BMI.
This study has several strengths, including its large size, data on a broad range of major potential confounders and excellent participant follow-up. However, observational associations can be subject to uncontrolled residual confounding. Additionally, the lack of more detailed anthropometric measures limits our ability to make mechanistic inferences. As AF development is casually linked to BMI and a series of clinical endpoints, by restricting enrolment to AF patients, the obtained associations between BMI and clinical endpoints are possibly subject to collider stratification bias. Studies that collect longitudinal BMI measurements preceding AF incidence and the application of time-varying exposure methods would help quantify the magnitude of this bias.
Our findings from this large-scale observational cohort suggest important associations between both high and low BMI and risk of mortality and new/worsening heart failure in those with AF. These findings are not in line with the so-called ‘obesity paradox’ and suggest that further investigation of weight management strategies in those with AF may reduce mortality and heart failure risk.
Data availability statement
All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information.
Patient consent for publication
This study involves human participants and was approved by Independent ethics committee and hospital-based institutional review board approvals were obtained.The GARFIELD-AF registry is conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki, local regulatory requirements and International Conference on Harmonization–Good Pharmacoepidemiological and Clinical Practice guidelines. Written informed consent was obtained from all study participants. There was no public or patient involvement in the design or execution of the GARFIELD-AF study design. Investigators from representative investigator sites in each participating country were involved in data collection. Confidentiality and anonymity were maintained through assigned unique identifiers. Independent ethics committee and hospital-based institutional review board approvals were obtained. A full list of ethics committees are provided in the supplemental material. Participants gave informed consent to participate in the study before taking part.
We would like to thank the physicians, nurses and patients involved in the GARFIELD AF registry. Editorial support was provided by Rebecca Watkin and Sidrah Rahman (Thrombosis Research Institute, London, UK)
Collaborators Global Steering Committee: GARFIELD-AF Registry Investigators: Ajay K Kakkar (UK) (Chair), Jean-Pierre Bassand (France), A John Camm (UK), David A Fitzmaurice (UK), Keith A A Fox (UK), Bernard J Gersh (USA), Samuel Z Goldhaber (USA), Shinya Goto (Japan), Sylvia Haas (Germany), Werner Hacke (Germany), Lorenzo G Mantovani (Italy), Frank Misselwitz (Germany), Karen S Pieper (USA), Alexander G G Turpie (Canada), Martin van Eickels (Germany) and Freek W A Verheugt (the Netherlands). Audit Committee: Keith A A Fox (UK) and Bernard J Gersh (USA). GARFIELD-AF National Coordinators: Hector Lucas Luciardi (Argentina), Harry Gibbs (Australia), Marianne Brodmann (Austria), Frank Cools (Belgium), Antonio Carlos Pereira Barretto (Brazil), Stuart J Connolly, John Eikelboom (Canada), Ramon Corbalan (Chile), Zhi-Cheng Jing (China), Petr Jansky (Czech Republic), Jørn Dalsgaard Nielsen (Denmark), Hany Ragy (Egypt), Pekka Raatikainen (Finland), Jean-Yves Le Heuzey (France), Harald Darius (Germany), Matyas Keltai (Hungary), Jitendra Pal Singh Sawhney (India), Giancarlo Agnelli and Giuseppe Ambrosio (Italy), Yukihiro Koretsune (Japan), Carlos Jerjes Sánchez Díaz (Mexico), Hugo Ten Cate (the Netherlands), Dan Atar (Norway), Janina Stepinska (Poland), Elizaveta Panchenko (Russia), Toon Wei Lim (Singapore), Barry Jacobson (South Africa), Seil Oh (South Korea), Xavier Viñolas (Spain), Marten Rosenqvist (Sweden), Jan Steffel (Switzerland), Pantep Angchaisuksiri (Thailand), Ali Oto (Turkey), Alex Parkhomenko (Ukraine), Wael Al Mahmeed (United Arab Emirates), David Fitzmaurice (UK) and Samuel Z Goldhaber (USA). GARFIELD-AF National Investigators: China: Dayi Hu, Kangning Chen, Yusheng Zhao, Huaiqin Zhang, Jiyan Chen, Shiping Cao, Daowen Wang, Yuejin Yang, Weihua Li, Hui Li, Yuehui Yin, Guizhou Tao, Ping Yang, Yingmin Chen, Shenghu He, Yong Wang, Guosheng Fu, Xin Li, Tongguo Wu, Xiaoshu Cheng, Xiaowei Yan, Ruiping Zhao, Moshui Chen, Longgen Xiong, Ping Chen, Yang Jiao, Ying Guo, Li Xue and Zhiming Yang. India: Praveen Jadhavm, Raghava Sarma, Govind Kulkarni, Prakash Chandwani, Rasesh Atulbhai Pothiwala, Mohanan Padinhare Purayil, Kamaldeep Chawla, Veerappa Annasaheb Kothiwale, Bagirath Raghuraman, Vinod Madan Vijan, Jitendra Sawhney, Ganapathi Bantwal, Aziz Khan, Ramdhan Meena, Manojkumar Chopada, Sunitha Abraham, Vikas Bisne, Govindan Vijayaraghavan, Debabrata Roy, Rajashekhar Durgaprasad, A G Ravi Shankar, Sunil Kumar, Dinesh Jain, Kartikeya Bhargava, Vinay Kumar, Udigala Madappa Nagamalesh and Rajeeve Kumar Rajput. Japan: Yukihiro Koretsune, Seishu Kanamori, Kenichi Yamamoto, Koichiro Kumagai, Yosuke Katsuda, Keiki Yoshida, Fumitoshi Toyota, Yuji Mizuno, Ikuo Misumi, Hiroo Noguchi, Shinichi Ando, Tetsuro Suetsugu, Masahiro Minamoto, Hiroyuki Oda, Susumu Adachi, Kei Chiba, Hiroaki Norita, Makoto Tsuruta, Takeshi Koyanagi, Kunihiko Yamamoto, Hiroshi Ando, Takayuki Higashi, Megumi Okada, Shiro Azakami, Shinichiro Komaki, Kenshi Kumeda, Takashi Murayama, Jun Matsumura, Yurika Oba, Ryuji Sonoda, Kazuo Goto, Kotaro Minoda, Yoshikuni Haraguchi, Hisakazu Suefuji, Hiroo Miyagi, Hitoshi Kato, Tsugihiro Nakamura, Tadashi Nakamura, Hidekazu Nandate, Ryuji Zaitsu, Yoshihisa Fujiura, Akira Yoshimura, Hiroyuki Numata, Jun Ogawa, Yasuyuki Kamogawa, Kinshiro Murakami, Yutaka Wakasa, Masanori Yamasawa, Hiromitsu Maekawa, Sumihisa Abe, Hajime Kihara, Satoru Tsunoda, Katsumi Saito, Hiroki Tachibana, Ichiro Oba, Takashi Kuwahata, Satoshi Higa, Masamichi Gushiken, Takuma Eto, Hidetoshi Chibana, Kazuaki Fujisawa, Yuhei Shiga, Hirokuni Sumi, Toshihisa Nagatomo, Yoshihiko Atsuchi, Toshiro Nagoshi, Kazuhisa Sanno, Fumihiro Hoshino, Naoto Yokota, Masahiro Kameko, Toshifumi Tabuchi, Munesumi Ishizawa, Yoshitake Fujiura, Daisuke Ikeda,Taku Seto, Tetsu Iwao, Norio Ishioka, Koichi Oshiro, Keizo Tsuchida, Yutaka Hatori, Motoshi Takeuchi, Hiroto Takezawa, Shinjiro Nagano, Masaaki Iwaki, Yuichiro Nakamura, Naomasa Miyamoto, Toshifumi Taguchi, Ko Ashida, Naoto Yoshizawa, Jun Agata, Seishiro Matsukawa, Osamu Arasaki, Shuji Fukuoka, Hirofumi Murakami, Kazuya Mishima, Yoshiki Hata, Ichiro Sakuma, Kotaro Obunai, Ichiro Takamura, Mitsuyuki Akutsu, Toshihide Unoki, Yoshinori Go, Makoto Ikemura, Shoji Morii, Shigeru Marusaki, Hideo Doi, Mitsuru Tanaka, Takaaki Kusumoto, Shigeo Kakinoki, Chiga Ogurusu, Kazuya Murata, Masaki Shimoyama, Masami Nakatsuka, Yutaka Kitami, Yoichi Nakamura, Hiroshi Oda, Rikimaru Oyama, Masato Ageta, Teruaki Mita, Kazuhiko Nagao, Takafumi Mito, Junichi Minami, Mitsunori Abe, Masako Fujii, Makoto Okawa, Tsuneo Fujito, Toshiya Taniguchi, Tenei Ko, Hiroshi Kubo, Mizuho Imamaki, Masahiro Akiyama, Takashi Ueda, Hironori Odakura, Masahiko Inagaki, Yoshiki Katsube, Atsuyuki Nakata, Shinobu Tomimoto, Mitsuhiro Shibuya, Masayuki Nakano, Kenichiro Ito, Masahiro Matsuta, Motoyuki Ishiguro, Taro Minagawa, Masamichi Wada, Hiroaki Mukawa, Masato Mizuguchi, Fumio Okuda, Teruaki Kimura, Kuniaki Taga, Masaaki Techigawara, Morio Igarashi, Hiroshi Watanabe, Toshihiko Seo, Shinya Hiramitsu, Hiroaki Hosokawa, Mitsumoto Hoshiai, Michitaka Hibino, Koichi Miyagawa, Hideki Horie, Nobuyoshi Sugishita, Yukio Shiga, Akira Soma, Kazuo Neya, Tetsuro Yoshida, Kunio Akahane, Sen Adachi, Chiei Takanaka, Takashi Ueda, Saori Matsui, Hirofumi Kanda, Masanori Kaneko, Shiro Nagasaka, Atsushi Taguchi, Shuta Toru, Kazuyuki Saito, Akiko Miyashita, Hiroki Sasaguri, Jin Nariyama, Taketo Hatsuno, Takash Iwase, Kazuki Sato, Kazuya Kawai, Tomobumi Kotani, Tsuyoshi Tsuji, Hirosumi Sakai, Kiyoshi Nishino, Kenichi Ikeda, Kazuo Maeda, Tomohiro Shinozuka, Takeshi Inoue, Koichi Kawakami, Hiromichi Kitazumi, Tsutomu Takagi, Mamoru Hamaoka, Jisho Kojima, Akitoshi Sasaki, Yoshihiro Tsuchiya, Tetsuo Betsuyaku, Koji Higuchi, Masaaki Honda, Koichi Hasegawa, Takao Baba, Kazuaki Mineoi, Toshihiko Koeda, Kunihiko Hirasawa, Toshihide Kumazaki, Akira Nakagomi, Eiji Otaki, Takashi Shindo, Hiroyoshi Hirayama, Chikako Sugimoto, Takashi Yamagishi, Ichiro Mizuguchi, Kazunori Sezaki, Isamu Niwa, Ken Takenaka, Osamu Iiji, Koichi Taya, Hitoshi Kitazawa, samu Ueda, Hirokazu Kakuda, Takuya Ono, Seizo Oriso, Junya Kamata, Toshihiko Nanke, Itaru Maeda, Yoshifusa Matsuura, Hiroki Teragawa, Yasuyuki Maruyama, Kazuo Takei, Hajime Horie, Tetsutaro Kito, Hiroshi Asano, Koji Matsushita, Masaichi Nakamura, Takashi Washizuka, Tomoki Yoshida, Masato Sawano, Shinichi Arima, Hidekazu Arai, Hisanori Shinohara, Hiroyuki Takai, Nobufusa Furukawa, Akira Ota, Kentaro Yamamoto, Kenji Aoki, Taku Yamamoto, Takeaki Kasai, Shunji Suzuki, Shu Suzuki, Nitaro Shibata, Masayuki Watanabe, Yosuke Nishihata, Toru Arino, Masaki Okuyama, Tetsushi Wakiyama, Tomoko Kato, Yasuo Sasagawa, Takeshi Tana, Yoshihito Hayashi, Shinichi Hirota, Yukihiko Abe, Yoshihiro Saito, Hirohide Uchiyama, Hiroshi Takeda, Hiroshi Ono, Shuichi Tohyo, Naoto Hanazono, Seiichi Miyajima, Hisashi Shimono, Takuma Aoyama, Yasunobu Shozawa, Yawara Niijima, Osamu Murai, Osamu Murai, Hideko Inaba, Katsumasa Nomura, Masatsugu Nozoe, Kazuo Suzuki, Toshiyuki Furukawa, Toshihiko Shiraiwa, Nobuhisa Ito, Shunichi Nagai, Kiyoharu Sato, Shiro Nakahara, Yujin Shimoyama, Naoko Ohara, Teruhiko Kozuka, Hideaki Okita, Masato Endo, Tsutomu Goto, Makoto Hirose, Emiko Nagata, Noriyuki Nakanishi, Toshizumi Mori, Shuichi Seki, Katsuhiro Okamoto, Osamu Moriai, Yoko Emura, Tsuyoshi Fukuda, Haruhiko Date, Shuichi Kawakami, Sho Nagai, Yuya Ueyama, Tetsuro Fudo, Mitsuru Imaizumi, Takuo Ogawa, Shunsuke Take, Hideo Ikeda, Hiroaki Nishioka, Norihiko Sakamoto, Kiyomitsu Ikeoka, Nobuo Wakaki, Masatake Abe, Junji Doiuchi, Tetsuya Kira, Masato Tada, Ken Tsuzaki, Naoya Miura, Yasuaki Fujisawa, Wataru Furumoto, Susumu Suzuki, Akinori Fujisawa, Ryosai Nakamura, Hiroyasu Komatsu, Rei Fujiki, Shuichi Kawano, Keijiro Nishizawa, Yoji Kato, Junya Azuma, Kiyoshi Yasui,Toshio Amano, Yasuhiro Sekine, Tatsuo Honzawa, Yuichiro Koshibu, Yasuhide Sakamoto, Yukihiro Seta, Shingo Miyaguchi, Kojuro Morishita, Yasuko Samejima, Toyoshi Sasaki, Fumiko Iseki, Toshiyuki Kobayashi, Hiroshi Kano, Jaeyoung Kim, Hiroshi Yamaguchi, Yoichi Takagi, Yoko Onuki Pearce, Yasuyuki Suzuki, Takayuki Fukui, Toru Nakayama, Hideaki Kanai, Yoshiyuki Kawano, Tetsuji Ino, Hironori Miyoshi, Yasufumi Miyamoto, Masahito Shigekiyo, Shimato Ono, Yoshiyuki Kawano, Yutaka Okamoto, Satoshi Ubukata, Kojiro Kodera, Tatsuo Oriuchi, Naoki Matsumoto, Koichi Inagaki, Atsushi Iseki, Tomohiro Yoshida, Toshihiro Goda, Tsukasa Katsuki, Atsushi Sato, Etsuo Mori, Toshio Tsubokura, Hiroshi Shudo, Shunichi Fujimoto, Tomohiro Katsuya, Yoshiyuki Furukawa, Hiroshi Hosokawa, Jun Narumi, Kiichiro Yamamoto, Masaki Owari, Takuya Inakura, Takafumi Anno and Kazuyuki Shirakawa. Singapore: Chi Keong Ching, Toon Wei Lim, David Foo, Kelvin Wong and Tan Yuyang. South Korea: Seil Oh, Hui Nam Park, Woo-Shik Kim, HyeYoung Lee, Sung-Won Jang, Dae Hyeok Kim, Jun Kim, DongRyeol Ryu, Jaemin Shim, Dae-Kyeong Kim, Dong Ju Choi, Yong Seog Oh, Myeong-Chan Cho, Hack-Lyoung Kim, Hui-Kyung Jeon, Dong-Gu Shin, Sang Weon Park, Hoon Ki Park, Sang-Jin Han, Jung Hoon Sung, Hyung-Wook Park, Gi-Byoung Nam, Young Keun On, Hong Euy Lim, JaeJin Kwak, Tae-Joon Cha, Taek Jong Hong, Seong Hoon Park, Jung Han Yoon, Nam-Ho Kim, Kee-Sik Kim, Byung Chun Jung, Gyo-Seung Hwang and Chong-Jin Kim. Thailand: Sakda Rungaramsin, Peerapat Katekangplu, Porames Khunrong, Thanita Bunyapipat, Wanwarang Wongcharoen, Pinij Kaewsuwanna, Khanchai Siriwattana, Waraporn Tiyanon, Supalerk Pattanaprichakul, Khanchit Likittanasombat, Doungrat Cholsaringkarl, Warangkana Boonyapisit, Sirichai Cheewatanakornkul, Songkwan Silaruks, Pisit Hutayanon, Seksan Chawanadelert, Pairoj Chattranukulchai, Boonsert Chatlaong, Yingsak Santanakorn, Khompiya Kanokphatcharakun, Piya Mongkolwongroj, Sasivimon Jai-Aue and Ongkarn Komson. Turkey: Armagan Altun, Ali Aydinlar, Ramazan Topsakal, Zeki Ongen, Sadik Acikel, Durmus Yildiray Sahin, Ozcan Yilmaz, Mehmet Birhan Yilmaz, Hasan Pekdemir, Mesut Demir, Murat Sucu, Levent Sahiner, Ali Oto, Murat Ersanli, Ertugrul Okuyan and Dursun Aras. Argentina: Florencia Rolandi, Adrian Cesar Ingaramo, Gustavo Alberto Sambadaro, Vanina Fernandez Caputi, Hector Luciardi, Sofia Graciela Berman, Pablo Dragotto, Andres Javier Kleiban, Nestor Centurion, Rodolfo Andres Ahuad Guerrero, Leonel Adalberto Di Paola, Ricardo Dario Dran, Javier Egido, Matias Jose Fosco, Victor Alfredo Sinisi, Luis Rodolfo Cartasegna, Oscar Gomez Vilamajo, Jose Luis Ramos, Sonia Sassone, Gerardo Zapata, Diego Conde, Guillermo Giacomi, Alberto Alfredo Fernandez, Mario Alberto Berli and Fabian Ferroni. Brazil: Dário Celestino Sobral Filho, Jefferson Jaber, Luciana Vidal Armaganijan, Costantino Roberto Frack Costantini, André Steffens, Weimar Kunz Sebba Barroso de Souzaem, João David de Souza Neto, José Márcio Ribeiro, Marcelo Silveira Teixeira, Paulo Rossi, Leonardo Pires, Daniel Moreira, José Carlos Moura Jorge, Adalberto Menezes Lorga Filho, Luiz Bodanese, Marcelo Westerlund Montera, Carlos Henrique Del Carlo, Jamil Abdalla Saad, Fernando Augusto Alves da Costa, Renato Lopes, Gilson Roberto de Araújo, Euler Roberto Manenti, Jose Francisco Kerr Saraiva, João Carlos Ferreira Braga, Alexandre Negri, Carlos Moncada, Dalton Precoma, Fernando Roquette, Gilmar Reis and Roberto Álvaro Ramos Filho, Estêvão Lanna Figueiredo, Roberto Vieira Botelho, Cláudio Munhoz da Fontoura Tavares, Helius Carlos Finimundi, Adriano Kochi, César Cássio Broilo França, Fábio Alban, Guido Bernardo Aranha Rosito, João Batista de Moura Xavier Moraes Junior, Rogério Tadeu Tumelero, Lilia Maia, Roberto Simões de Almeida, Ney Carter do Carmo Borges and Luís Gustavo Gomes Ferreira. Chile: Ramón Corbalán, Benjamin Aleck Joseh Stockins Fernandez, Humberto Montecinos, Fernando Lanas, Martín Larico Gómez, Carlos Astudillo, Carlos Conejeros, Patricio Marin Cuevas, Alejandro Forero, Claudio Bugueño Gutiérrez, Juan Aguilar, Sergio Potthoff Cardenas, German Eggers, Cesar Houzvic, Carlos Rey, Germán Arriagada and Gustavo Charme Vilches. Mexico: Carlos Jerjes Sanchez Diaz, Jesus Jaime Illescas Diaz, Raul Leal Cantu, Maria Guadalupe Ramos Zavala, Ricardo, Cabrera Jardines, Nilda Espinola Zavaleta, Enrique Lopez Rosas, Guillermo Antonio Llamas Esperón, Gerardo Pozas, Ernesto Cardona Muñoz, Norberto Matadamas Hernandez, Adolfo Leyva Rendon, Norberto Garcia Hernandez, Manuel de los Rios Ibarra, Luis Ramon Virgen Carrillo, David Lopez Villezca, Carlos Hernandez Herrera, Juan Jose Lopez Prieto, Rodolfo Gaona Rodriguez, Efrain Villeda Espinosa, David Flores Martinez, Jose Velasco Barcena, Omar Fierro Fierro, Ignacio Rodriguez Briones, Jose Luis Leiva Pons, Humberto Alvarez Lopez, Rafael Olvera Ruiz, Carlos Gerardo Cantu Brito, Eduardo Julian Jose Roberto Chuquiure Valenzuela, Roxana Reyes Sanchez, Alberto Esteban Bazzoni Ruiz, Oscar Martin Lopez Ruiz, Roberto Arriaga Nava, Jesus David Morales Cerda, Pedro Fajardo Campos and Mario Benavides Gonzalez. Austria: Marianne Brodmann, Kurt Lenz, Claus Hagn, Johannes Foechterle, Heinz Drexel, Kurt Huber, Andrea Podczeck- Schweighofer, Michael Winkler, Bruno Schneeweiss, Alfons Gegenhuber, Wilfried Lang, Sabine Eichinger-Hasenauer, Peter Kaserer, Josef Sykora, Heribert Rasch and Bernhard Strohmer. Belgium: Luc Capiau, Geert Vervoort, Bart Wollaert, Frank Cools, Geert Hollanders, Jan Vercammen, Dirk Faes, Yohan Balthazar, Marc Delforge, Olivier Xhaet, Harry Striekwold, John Thoeng, Kurt Hermans, Georges Mairesse, Wim Anné, Ivan Blankoff, Michel Beutels, Stefan Verstraete, Peter Vandergoten, Philippe Purnode, Pascal Godart, Tim Boussy, Philippe Desfontaines, Alex Heyse, Joeri Voet and Axel De Wolf. Czech Republic: Eva Zidkova, Petr Jansky, Rudolf Spacek, Vilma Machova, Ondrej Ludka, Josef Olsr, Lubos Kotik, Blazej Racz, Richard Ferkl, Jan Hubac, Ilja Kotik, Zdenek Monhart, Hana Burianova, Ondrej Jerabek, Jana Pisova, Iveta Petrova, Vratislav Dedek, Michaela Honkova, Petr Podrazil, Petr Reichert, Jindrich Spinar, Miroslav Novak, Vaclav Durdil, Katarina Plocova and Jiri Lastuvka. Denmark: Jørn Nielsen, Steen Husted, Helena Dominguez, Ulrik Hintze, Søren Rasmussen, Næstved Sygehus, Arne Bremmelgaard, John Markenvard, Jan Børger, Jorgen Solgaard, Ebbe Eriksen, Thomas Løkkegaard, Michael Bruun, Jacob Mertz, Morten Schou, Helena Dominguez and Michael Olsen. Finland: Pekka Raatikainen, Carmela Viitanen. France: Franck Paganelli, Joël Ohayon, Frédéric Casassus, Jean-Yves Le Heuzey, Michel Galinier, Yannick Gottwalles, Philippe Loiselet, Jean-Joseph Muller, Mohamed Bassel Koujan, André Marquand, Sylvain Destrac, Olivier Piot, Nicolas Delarche, Jean-Pierre Cebron, Maxime Guenoun, Dominique Guedj-Meynier, Lokesh A G, Mathieu Zuber, Pierre Amarenco, Emmanuel Ellie, James Kadouch, Pierre-Yves Fournier, Jean-Pierre Huberman, Nestor Lemaire, Gilles Rodier, Xavier Vandamme, Igor Sibon, Jean-Philippe Neau, Marie Hélène Mahagne, Antoine Mielot, Marc Bonnefoy, Jean-Baptiste Churet, Vincent Navarre, Frederic Sellem, Gilles Monniot, Jean-Paul Boyes, Bernard Doucet, Michel Martelet, Désiré Obadia, Bernard Crousillat, Joseph Mouallem, Etienne Bearez, Jean Philippe Brugnaux, Alain Fedorowsky, Pierre Nazeyrollas, Jean-Baptiste Berneau and Frédéric Chemin. Germany: Sebastien Schellong, Harald Darius, Georg Koeniger, Andreas Kopf, Uwe Gerbaulet, Bernd-Thomas Kellner, Thomas Schaefer, Jan Purr, Enno Eißfeller, Heinz-Dieter Zauzig, Peter Riegel, Christoph Axthelm, Gerd-Ulrich Heinz, Holger Menke, Andreas Pustelnik, Stefan Zutz, Wolfgang Eder, Guenter Rehling, Dirk Glatzel, Norbert Ludwig, Petra Sandow, Henning Wiswedel, Cosmas Wildenauer, Steffen Schoen, Toralf Schwarz, Adyeri Babyesiza, Maximilian Kropp, Hans-Hermann Zimny, Friedhelm Kahl, Andreas Caspar, Sabine Omankowsky, Torsten Laessig, Hermann-Josef Hartmann, Gunter Lehmann, Hans-Walter Bindig, Gunter Hergdt, Dietrich Reimer, Joachim Hauk, Holger Michel, Praxis Dres. Werner Erdle, Wilfried Dorsch, Janna Dshabrailov, Karl-Albrecht Rapp, Reinhold Vormann, Thomas Mueller, Peter Mayer, Uwe Horstmeier, Volker Eissing, Heinz Hey, Heinz Leuchtgens, Volker Lilienweiss, Heiner Mueller, Christian Schubert, Herrmann Lauer, Thomas Buchner, Gunter Brauer, Susanne Kamin, Karsten Mueller, Sylvia Baumbach, Muwafeg Abdel-Qader, Hans-Holger Ebert, Carsten Schwencke, Peter Bernhardt, Laszlo Karolyi, Britta Sievers, Wilhelm Haverkamp and Jens-Uwe Roehnisch. Hungary: Andras Vertes, Gabor Szantai, Andras Matoltsy, Nikosz Kanakaridisz, Zoltan Boda, Erno Kis, Balazs Gaszner, Ferenc Juhasz, Gizella Juhasz, Sandor Kancz, Zoltan Laszlo, Zsolt May, Bela Merkely, Ebrahim Noori, Tamas Habon, Peter Polgar, Gabriella Szalai, Sandor Vangel, Andras Nagy, Gabriella Engelthaler, Judit Ferenczi and Mihaly Egyutt. Italy: Giuliana Martini, Leone Maria Cristina, Eros Tiraferri, Rita Santoro, Sophie Testa, Giovanni Di Minno, Marco Moia, Teresa Maria Caimi, Maria Tessitori, Giancarlo Agnelli, Roberto Cappelli, Daniela Poli, Roberto Quintavalla, Franco Cosmi, Raffaele Fanelli, Vincenzo Oriana, Raffaele Reggio, Roberto Santi, Leonardo Pancaldi, Raimondo De Cristofaro, Giuliana Guazzaloca, Angelo De Blasio, Jorge Salerno Uriate, Flavia Lillo, Enrico Maria Pogliani, Grzegorz Bilo, Michele Accogli, Antonio Mariani, Mauro Feola, Arturo Raisaro, Luciano Fattore, Andrea Mauric, Fabrizio Germini, Luca Tedeschi, Maria Settimi, Sergio Nicoli, Paolo Ricciarini, Antonio Argena, Paolo Ronchini, Claudio Bulla, Filippo Tradati, Massimo Volpe, Maria D'Avino, Maria Grazia Bongiorni, Silva Severi, Alessandro Capucci, Corrado Lodigiani, Enrico Salomone, Gaetano Serviddio, Claudio Tondo, Giuseppe Ambrosio, Paolo Golino, Carmine Mazzone and Saverio Iacopino. The Netherlands: Hugo ten Cate, J H Ruiter, Andreas Lucassen, Henk Adriaansen, Maarten Bongaerts, Mathijs Pieterse, Coen van Guldener, Johannes Herrman, S H K P R Nierop, Pieter Hoogslag, Walter Hermans, B E Groenemeijer, W Terpstra, Cees Buiks and L V A Boersma. Norway: Eivind Berge, Per Anton Sirnes, Erik Gjertsen, Torstein Hole, Knut Erga, Arne Hallaråker, Gunnar Skjelvan, Anders Østrem, Beraki Ghezai, Arne Svilaas, Peter Christersson, Torbjørn Øien, Svein Høegh Henrichsen, Jan Erik Otterstad, Jan Berg-Johansen. Poland: Janina Stepinska, Andrzej Gieroba, Malgorzata Biedrzycka, Michal Ogorek, Beata Wozakowska-Kaplon, Krystyna Loboz-Grudzien, Jaroslaw, Wieslaw Supinski, Jerzy Kuzniar, Roman Zaluska, Jaroslaw Hiczkiewicz, Lucyna Swiatkowska-Byczynska, Lech Kucharski, Marcin Gruchala, Piotr Minc, Maciej Olszewski, Grzegorz Kania, Malgorzata Krzciuk, Zbigniew Lajkowski, Bozenna Ostrowska-Pomian, Jerzy Lewczuk, Elzbieta Zinka, Agnieszka Karczmarczyk, Malgorzata Chmielnicka-Pruszczynska, Iwona Wozniak-Skowerska, Grzegorz Opolski, Marek Bronisz, Marcin Ogorek, Grazyna Glanowska, Piotr Ruszkowski, Grzegorz Skonieczny, Ryszard Sciborski, Boguslaw Okopien, Piotr Kukla, Krzysztof Galbas, Krzysztof Cymerman, Jaroslaw Jurowiecki, Pawel Miekus, Waldemar Myszka, Stanislaw Mazur, Roman Lysek, Jacek Baszak, Teresa Rusicka-Piekarz, Grzegorz Raczak, Ewa Domanska, Jadwiga Nessler and Jozef Lesnik. Russia: Vera Eltishcheva, Roman Libis, Gadel Kamalov, Dmitry Belenky, Liudmila Egorova, Alexander Khokhlov, Eduard Yakupov, Dmitry Zateyshchikov, Olga Barbarash, Olga Miller, Evgeniy Mazur, Konstantin Zrazhevskiy, Tatyana Novikova, Yulia Moiseeva, Elena Polkanova, Konstantin Sobolev, Maria Rossovskaya, Yulia Shapovalova, Alla Kolesnikova, Konstantin Nikolaev, Oksana Zemlianskaia, Anna Zateyshchikova, Victor Kostenko, Sergey Popov, Maria Poltavskaya, Anton Edin, Elena Aleksandrova, Oksana Drapkina, Alexander Vishnevsky, Oleg Nagibovich, Petr Chizhov, Svetlana Rachkova, Mikhail Sergeev, Borys Kurylo and Alexey Ushakov. Spain: Xavier Vinolas, Pere Alvarez Garcia, Maria Fernanda Lopez Fernandez, Luis Tercedor Sanchez, Salvador Tranche Iparraguirre, Pere Toran Monserrat, Emilio Marquez Contreras, Jordi Isart Rafecas, Juan Motero Carrasco, Pablo Garcia Pavia, Casimiro Gomez Pajuelo, Luis Miguel Rincon Diaz, Luis Fernando Iglesias Alonso, Angel Grande Ruiz, Jordi Merce Klein, Jose Ramon Gonzalez Juanatey, Ines Monte Collado, Herminia Palacin Piquero, Carles Brotons Cuixart, Esther Fernandez Escobar, Joan Bayo i Llibre, Cecilia Corros Vicente, Manuel Vida Gutierrez, Francisco Epelde Gonzalo, Carlos Alexandre Almeida Fernandez, Encarnacion Martinez Navarro, Jordi Isart Rafecas, Juan Jose Montero Alia, Maria Barreda Gonzalez, Maria Angels Moleiro Oliva, Jose Iglesias Sanmartin, Mercedes Jimenez Gonzalez, Maria del Mar Rodriguez Alvarez, Juan Herreros Melenchon, Tomas Ripoll Vera, Manuel Jimenez Navarro, Maria Vazquez Caamano, Maria Fe Arcocha Torres, Gonzalo Marcos Gomez, Andres Iniguez Romo and Miguel Angel Prieto Diaz. Sweden: Mårten Rosenqvist, Alexander Wirdby, Centrumkliniken, Jan Lindén, Kerstin Henriksson, Micael Elmersson, Arnor Egilsson, Ulf Börjesson, Gunnar Svärd, Bo Liu, Anders Lindh, Lars-Bertil Olsson, Mikael Gustavsson, Lars Andersson, Lars Benson, Claes Bothin, Ali Hajimirsadeghi, Björn Martinsson, Marianne Ericsson, Åke Ohlsson, Håkan Lindvall, Peter Svensson, Katarina Thörne, Hans Händel, Pyotr Platonov, Fredrik Bernsten, Ingar Timberg, Milita Crisby, Jan-Erik Karlsson, Agneta Andersson, Lennart Malmqvist, Johan Engdahl, Jörgen Thulin, Aida Hot-Bjelak, Steen Jensen and Per Stalby. Switzerland: Jan Steffel, Johann Debrunner, Juerg H Beer and Dipen Shah. Ukraine: Iurii Rudyk, Vira Tseluyko, Oleksandr Karpenko, Svitlana Zhurba, Igor Kraiz, Oleksandr Parkhomenko, Iryna Kupnovytska, Nestor Seredyuk, Yuriy Mostovoy, Oleksiy Ushakov, Olena Koval, Igor Kovalskiy, Yevgeniya Svyshchenko, Oleg Sychov, Mykola Stanislavchuk, Andriy Yagensky, Susanna Tykhonova and Ivan Fushtey. UK: Will Murdoch, Naresh Chauhan, Daryl Goodwin, Louise Lumley, Ramila Patel, Philip Saunders, Bennett Wong, Alex Cameron, Philip Saunders, Niranjan Patel, P Jhittay, Andrew Ross, M S Kainth, Karim Ladha, Kevin Douglas, Gill Pickavance, Joanna McDonnell, Laura Handscombe, Trevor Gooding, Helga Wagner, Cumberlidge, Colin Bradshaw, Catherine Bromham, Kevin Jones, Shoeb Suryani, Richard Coates, Bhupinder Sarai, W Willcock, S Sircar, John Cairns, A Gilliand, Roman Bilas, E Strieder, Peter Hutchinson, Anne Wakeman, Michael Stokes, Graham Kirby, Bhaskhar Vishwanathan, Nigel Bird, Paul Evans, M Clark, John Bisatt, Jennifer Litchfield, E Fisher, Tim Fooks, Richard Kelsall, Neil Paul, Elizabeth Alborough, Michael Aziz, C Ramesh, Pete Wilson, Simon Franklin, Sue Fairhead, Julian Thompson, Hasan Chowan, Gary Taylor, Dawn Tragen, Matt Parfitt, Claire Seamark, Carolyn Paul, Mark Richardson, Angus Jefferies, Helen Sharp, Hywel Jones, Claire Giles, Matthew Bramley, Philip Williams, Jehad Aldegather, Simon Wetherell, William Lumb, Phil Evans, Frances Scouller, Neil Macey, Stephen Rogers, Yvette Stipp, Richard West, Philip Pinney, Paul Wadeson, John Matthews, Preeti Pandya, Andrew Gallagher, T Railton, Emyr Davies, Jonathan McClure, Marc Jacobs, Claire Hutton, R Thompson, Bijoy Sinha, Keith Butter, Susan Barrow, Helen Little, David Russell, Ulka Choudhary, Ikram Haq, Paul Ainsworth, Claire Jones, Phil Weeks, Jane Eden, Lisa Gibbons, Janet Glencross, Alison MacLeod, K Poland, Conor Mulolland, A Warke, Paul Conn, D Burns, R Smith, R Kamath, Jonathan Webster, Ian Hodgins, Stephen Vercoe, Paul Roome, Hilary Pinnock, Jayesh Patel, Amar Ali, Nigel Hart, Richard Davies, Nigel De-Sousa, Catherine Neden, Mark Danielsen, Purnima Sharma, Sophia Galloway, Charlotte Hawkins, Raife Oliver, Martin Aylward, Mira Pattni, Gordon Irvine, Shahid Ahmad, Catherine Rothwell, Fiaz Choudhary, Sabrina Khalaque, Stephanie Short, Sharon Peters, Warwick Coulson, Neil Roberts, Amy Butler, Steven Coates, Ben Ward, Daniel Jackson, Steve Walton, Diane Shepherd, Toh Wong, Mark Boon, Melanie Deacon, David Cornelius, Sarah Davies, Ben Frankel, Nick Hargreaves, Henry Choi, Jon Sumner, Tim Myhill, Salah Estifanos, Diane Geatch, Justin Wilkinson, Richard Veale, Karen Forshaw, Rob Hirst, Kashif Zaman, Catherine Liley, Rebecca Wastling, Paul McEleny, Andre Beattie, Philip Cooke, Mike Wong, Mark Pugsley, Chaminda Dooldeniya, Greg Rogers, James Bennett, Polly Jacobs, Rajesh Muvva, Matthew Adam, Robin Fox, Nicolas Thomas, Simon Cartwright, Rory Reed, Simon Randfield, Christine A'Court, Ann Flynn, Andrew Halpin, Shoeb Suryani, Simon Dobson, Louise Lomax, Minnal Nadaph, Iain Munro, Jane Goram, Helen Stoddart, Phil Simmons, John Shewring, Emma Bowen-Simpkins, Mark Rickenbach and Polly Jacobs. Australia: Adam Blenkhorn, Bhuwanendu Singh, Penny Astridge, William van Gaal, Walter Abhayaratna, Philip Thomson, Ron Lehman, Jens Kilian, David Coulshed, Andrei Catanchin, David Colquhoun, Hosen Kiat, David Eccleston, John French, Bronte Ayres, Peter Blombery, Thanh Phan, James Rogers, David O'Donnell, Sang Cheol Bae, Harry Gibbs, Patrick Carroll, Greg Starmer, Margaret Arstall, Maurits Binnekamp and Astin Lee. Canada: John Eikelboom, Robert Luton, Milan Gupta, Amritanshu Shekhar Pandey, Stephen Cheung, Rolland Leader, Philippe Beaudry, Félix Ayala-Paredes, Joseph Berlingieri, John Heath, Germain Poirier, Miranda du Preez, Bradley Schweitzer, Reginald Nadeau, Ripple Dhillon, Tomasz Hruczkowski, Andrea Lavoie, Ratika Parkash, James Cha, Benoit Coutu, Paul MacDonald, Brian Ramjattan, Jorge Bonet, Saul Vizel, Paul Angaran and Sameh Fikry. Egypt: Ahmed Mowafy, Azza Katta, Mazen Tawfik, Moustafa Nawar, Mohamed Sobhy, Seif Kamal Abou Seif, Tarek Khairy, Ahmed Abd El-Aziz, Nasser Taha, Ashraf Reda, Atef Elbahry, Mohamed Setiha, Mohamed Gamal El Din, Magdi Elkhadem and Adel El-Etreby. South Africa: David Kettles, Junaid Bayat, Heidi Siebert, Adrian Horak, Ynez Kelfkens, Riaz Garda, Barry Jacobson, Thayabran Pillay, Michele Guerra, Louis van Zyl, Hendrik Theron, Andrew Murray, Rikus Louw, Deon Greyling, Pindile Mntla, Siddique Ismail, Fayzal Ahmed, Johannes Engelbrecht, Shambu Maharajh, Wessel Oosthuysen, Rehana Loghdey and Veronica Ueckermann. United Arab Emirates: Wael Al Mahmeed, Abdullah Al Naeemi, Ghazi Yousef, Nooshin Bazargani, Munther AlOmairi, Rajan Maruthanayagam, Rupesh Singh, Ahmed Naguib, Mohamed Ibrahim, Amrish Agrawal, Mukesh Nathani, Ehab M. Esheiba, Adel Wassef and Rajeev Gupta. USA: Michael Cox, Scott Beach, Peter Duffy, Stephen Falkowski, Kevin Ferrick, Miguel Franco, W Michael Kutayli, Annette Quick, Niraj Sharma, Vance Wilson, Stephen Miller, Mark Alberts, Edwin Blumberg, Roddy Canosa, Ted Gutowski, Rodney Ison, Jorge Garcia, Paul Mullen, Howard Noveck, Pamela Rama, Rajneesh Reddy, Marcus Williams, Daniel Nishijima, Keith Ferdinand, Ihsan Haque, Robert Mendelson, Sridevi Pitta, Daniel Theodoro, Charles Treasure, Moustafa Moustafa, Cas Cader, Walter Pharr, Alisha Oropallo, George Platt, Jaspal Gujral, James Welker and Firas Koura.
Contributors All authors contributed to data analysis, provided interpretation of the results and contributed to the drafting and critical review of the manuscript. SV led the data analysis. GK and AK were responsible for funding. All authors approved the final draft of the manuscript. FC is responsible for the overall content as guarantor.
Funding This work was supported by the Thrombosis Research Institute (London, UK).
Competing interests CFC: research funding from British Heart Foundation. SG: research funding from MEXT/JSPS KAKENHI and grant support from the Agency for Medical Research and Development in Japan, and The Vehicle Racing Commemorative Foundation, Nakatani Foundation for Advancement of Measuring Technologies in Biomedical Engineering, Ono Pharma, Bristol Myers Squibb, Sanofi and Pfizer. Personal fees from Thrombosis Research Institute and the American Heart Association. MvE: employee of Bayer AG. SH: personal fees from Aspen, Bayer, BMS, Daiichi-Sankyo, Portola, Sanofi, outside the submitted work; BJG: Data Safety Monitoring Board–Mount Sinai St Luke’s, Boston Scientific Corporation, Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd, St Jude Medical Inc, Janssen Research & Development LLC, Thrombosis Research Institute, Duke Clinical Research Institute, Duke University, Kowa Research Institute Inc, Cardiovascular Re-search Foundation and Medtronic and general consulting for Janssen Scientific Affairs, Xenon Pharmaceuticals, and Sirtex Medical Limited. KP: consultant for Thrombosis Research Institute, AstraZeneca and Bayer; KAAF: grants from Bayer, Johnson and Johnson and Astra Zeneca; personal fees from Bayer, Johnson and Johnson, Lilly, Astra Zeneca and Sanofi/Regeneron; DAF: personal fees from BMS/Pfizer, Boehringer-Ingelheim, Daiichi Sankyo and Bayer; FM: employee of Bayer AG; AGGT: personal fees from Bayer Healthcare, Janssen Pharmaceutical Research & Development LLC, Astellas, Portola and Takeda; SZG: research grants from BiO2 Medical, Boehringer-Ingelheim, BMS, BTG EKOS, Daiichi, Janssen, NHLBI, Thrombosis Research Institute, personal fee from Agile, Bayer, Boehringer-Ingelheim, BMS, Daiichi, Janssen, Portola and Zafgen; FWAV: grants from Bayer Healthcare; personal fees from Bayer Healthcare, BMS/Pfizer, Daiichi-Sankyo and Boehringer-Ingelheim; AJC: personal fees from Bayer, personal fees from Boehringer Ingelheim, personal fees from Pfizer/BMS, personal fees from Daiichi Sankyo, outside the submitted work; EP: personal fees from Sanofi, Takeda, Boehringer Ingelheim, Pfizer, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Bayer and AstraZeneca; SO: consultant/advisory board payments from Bayer Pharma AG, Bristol-Myers Squibb Korea, Boehringer-Ingelheim Korea, Pfizer Korea, Sanofi-Aventis and St Jude Medical. JPSS: personal fee from Pfizer, Astra Zeneca, Novartis, Sanofi & BMS. HtC: research support from Bayer; consulting fees from Pfizer, Leo, Bayer, Alexion and Alveron; stockholder coagulation profile. JE: consulting fees and/or honoraria: Astra-Zeneca, Bayer, Boehringer-Ingelheim, Bristol-Myer-Squibb,Daiichi-Sankyo, Eli-Lilly, Glaxo-Smith-Kline, Pfizer, Janssen and Sanofi-Aventis; grants and/or in-kind support: Astra-Zeneca, Bayer, Boehringer-Ingelheim, Bristol-Myer-Squibb, Glaxo-SmithKline, Pfizer, Janssen and Sanofi-Aventis. AKK: grants from Bayer AG and Sanofi; personal fees from Bayer AG, Janssen, Pfizer, Sanofi, Verseon and Anthos Therapeutics. JPB, SV, GK, HLL, SC and PA declare no conflicts of interest.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Supplemental material This content has been supplied by the author(s). It has not been vetted by BMJ Publishing Group Limited (BMJ) and may not have been peer-reviewed. Any opinions or recommendations discussed are solely those of the author(s) and are not endorsed by BMJ. BMJ disclaims all liability and responsibility arising from any reliance placed on the content. Where the content includes any translated material, BMJ does not warrant the accuracy and reliability of the translations (including but not limited to local regulations, clinical guidelines, terminology, drug names and drug dosages), and is not responsible for any error and/or omissions arising from translation and adaptation or otherwise.