Article Text


Original research article
Subclinical cardiopulmonary dysfunction in stage 3 chronic kidney disease
  1. Alexander Nelson1,
  2. James Otto2,
  3. John Whittle3,
  4. Robert C M Stephens4,
  5. Daniel S Martin2,
  6. John R Prowle5 and
  7. Gareth L Ackland5
  1. 1UCL Medical School, London, UK
  2. 2Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
  3. 3Division of Medicine, Department of Clinical Physiology, University College London, London, UK
  4. 4Department of Anaesthesia, University College London Hospitals NHS Trust, London, UK
  5. 5William Harvey Research Institute, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Gareth L Ackland; g.ackland{at}


Objective Reduced exercise capacity is well documented in end-stage chronic kidney disease (CKD), preceded by changes in cardiac morphology in CKD stage 3. However, it is unknown whether subclinical cardiopulmonary dysfunction occurs in CKD stage 3 independently of heart failure.

Methods Prospective observational cross-sectional study of exercise capacity assessed by cardiopulmonary exercise testing in 993 preoperative patients. Primary outcome was peak oxygen consumption (VO2peak). Anaerobic threshold (AT), oxygen pulse and exercise-evoked measures of autonomic function were analysed, controlling for CKD stage 3, age, gender, diabetes mellitus and hypertension.

Results CKD stage 3 was present in 93/993 (9.97%) patients. Diabetes mellitus (RR 2.49 (95% CI 1.59 to 3.89); p<0.001), and hypertension (RR 3.20 (95% CI 2.04 to 5.03); p<0.001)) were more common in CKD stage 3. Cardiac failure (RR 0.83 (95% CI 0.30 to 2.24); p=0.70) and ischaemic heart disease (RR 1.40 (95% CI 0.97 to 2.02); p=0.09) were not more common in CKD stage 3. Patients with CKD stage 3 had lower predicted VO2peak (mean difference: 6% (95% CI 1% to 11%); p=0.02), lower peak heart rate (mean difference:9 bpm (95% CI 3 to 14); p=0.03)), lower AT (mean difference: 1.1 mL/min/kg (95% CI 0.4 to 1.7); p<0.001) and impaired heart rate recovery (mean difference: 4 bpm (95% CI 1 to 7); p<0.001)).

Conclusions Subclinical cardiopulmonary dysfunction in CKD stage 3 is common. This study suggests that maladaptive cardiovascular/autonomic dysfunction may be established in CKD stage 3, preceding pathophysiology reported in end-stage CKD.

Statistics from

Key questions

What is already known about this subject?

  • Early chronic kidney disease (CKD) is associated with structural cardiac changes, but the functional significance of this has not been explored.

What does this study add?

  • Using cardiopulmonary exercise testing, we show that early CKD is associated with subclinical, inferior cardiopulmonary reserve and evidence for autonomic dysfunction.

How might this impact on clinical practice?

  • These data contribute new insights into why early CKD appears to be associated with worse clinical outcomes across a range of clinical scenarios, including percutaneous coronary intervention, cardiac and non-cardiac surgery.


Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is associated with increased cardiovascular risk1 and mortality2 and increased incidence of cardiac failure.3–5 Reduced exercise capacity in patients with end-stage renal disease6 is associated with poor survival.7–9 In patients with end-stage renal disease, the combination of increased left ventricular mass, myocardial fibrosis, elevated left ventricular filling pressure and arterial stiffness are associated with reduced exercise capacity.10 Similarly, autonomic abnormalities have been described in end-stage (haemodialysis-dependent) CKD.11 ,12 By contrast, there is surprisingly few data on the association between impaired cardiac and/or autonomic function in asymptomatic patients with early CKD (CKD stage 3). Although changes in cardiac structure occur at different stages of estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR),13 no significant associations between kidney function and systolic or diastolic cardiac function have been found even after adjusting for potential confounding variables.13 In this prospective, cross-sectional observational study, we hypothesised that subclinical cardiopulmonary dysfunction in CKD stage 3 may be unmasked by objectively assessing cardiopulmonary reserve using cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET).


IRB approval (MREC: 12/LO/0453) was obtained in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Adherence to STROBE guidelines is documented in online supplementary material. Patients were enrolled prospectively at University College London Hospitals, UK (from December 2007 to May 2014), referred by their clinical team for CPET as part of routine standard-of-care preoperative assessment. Patients gave written consent to use CPET data. Exclusion criteria for CPET were in accordance with international guidelines.14 Adherence to STROBE guidelines is documented in the online supplementary material.

CKD assessment

eGFR was calculated from routine preoperative creatinine measurements using the modification of diet in renal disease (MDRD) equation,15 in line with most previous perioperative studies in the non-cardiac surgical populations. As we were primarily interested in categorising eGFR<60 mL/min/1.73 m2, potential inaccuracy of MDRD at higher levels of GFR was not a major consideration. CKD stage was defined from eGFR according to Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) 2012 clinical practice guideline for the evaluation and management of chronic kidney disease. As data on urinalysis and cystatin C was not available for the purposes of this study, presence of CKD stage 3 was defined as eGFR 45–60 mL min.1.73 m2.

CPET performance

Investigators blinded to CKD stage carried out all exercise testing. Equipment was calibrated before each test using standard reference gases. Patients undertook CPET on an electronically controlled cycle ergometer (Zan, nSpire, Colorado, USA; Lode, Groningen, The Netherlands) to maximal tolerance, adhering to the timed protocol detailed in online supplementary figure S1. Continuous 12-lead ECG was recorded. Continuous breath-by-breath gas exchange analysis was performed, with on-line calculations of oxygen consumption (VO2; mL/kg/min), minute ventilation (VE), carbon dioxide production (VCO2) and respiratory exchange ratio (RER; VCO2/VO2). Before each test, the pneumotachometer was referenced by calibrating the gas analysers with a certified air mixture, according to the manufacturer's specifications. All patients were instructed to continue cycling until symptom-limited fatigue. CPET data were analysed blinded to CKD status. Anaerobic threshold (AT) was determined by two independent assessors blinded to autonomic parameters, and according to published guidelines using the modified V-slope method, and confirmed by ventilatory equivalents for carbon dioxide (Embedded Image) and oxygen (Embedded Image).16 ,17 Peak oxygen consumption (Embedded Image), oxygen pulse and Embedded Image were also recorded. Embedded Image is inversely related to cardiac output at peak exercise,18 and is a better predictor of outcome in heart failure.19 Predicted values, derived from population norms that take into account age, gender, weight and height, were calculated for Embedded Image20 and oxygen pulse,21 a robust measure of left ventricular stroke volume.22 ,23 Per cent predicted peak Embedded ImageO2 values (derived from the Wasserman/Hansen equations) are a superior measure of these variables, at least in patients with established heart failure.24

Assessment of exercise-evoked ischaemia

Continuous 12-lead ECG recordings were made throughout the CPET period to enable the detection of ischaemia and/or development of dysrhythmias. ST-segment depression was quantified in lead II, which is superior for detection of atrial dysrhythmias, and more easily obtained with conventional monitors.25 Lead II ST changes were defined as abnormal when ST depression of 0.1 mV (1 mm) or more occurred, in accordance with current American College of Cardiology guidelines,26 and consistent with previous studies identifying that ST-segment depression to levels ≥1 mm independently predict future cardiac events in asymptomatic populations.27

Autonomic assessment

Autonomic data were analysed offline, blinded to CKD status and postoperative outcomes. Exercise-evoked sympathetic and parasympathetic autonomic responses were assessed following the CPET protocol as described above. Patients undertook 3 min of unloaded pedalling prior to the initiation of ramped exercise. Heart rate readings were obtained via ECG with the patient sitting on the cycle ergometer. All patients acclimatised for 3 min on the ergometer prior to start exercise. Non-invasive blood pressure was measured at the start (zero workload) and at the end of CPET. Sympathetic dysfunction was defined as the early acceleration of heart rate prior to exercise (AHRR), that is, the difference between the heart rate at rest and the heart rate measured just before starting loaded pedalling during the exercise test protocol (ie, after 3 min of unloaded exercise). Parasympathetic dysfunction was defined from heart rate recovery at 1 min following the cessation of exercise. We defined an abnormal heart rate recovery as a failure to decrease heart rate by ≥12 bpm 1 min after the end of exercise, based on extensive previous data showing an association between heart rate recovery and an increased risk of cardiovascular and all-cause cardiovascular death.28 ,29


The primary outcome was Embedded Image. Secondary outcomes were AT, Embedded Image, oxygen pulse, anticipatory heart rate and heart rate recovery. Baseline characteristics of participants were compared according to presence of CKD stage 3 using general linear models of analysis of variance (quantitative variables), controlling for age as a covariate where CPET variables are not referenced to population norms. Non-parametric data were analysed with the Kruskal-Wallis test. Categorical variables were analysed using Fisher’s exact test. Multivariate analysis to establish clinical predictors of peak VO2 took into account age (continuous variable) and the following categorical variables: gender, malignancy, hypertension, cardiac failure, diabetes mellitus and CKD stage 3. All reported p values are two sided, with significance set at p≤0.05. Statistical analyses were performed using NCSS 8 (Kaysville, Utah, USA).

Sample size calculation

On the basis of previous cardiac structural studies, a prevalence of 48% left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) occurs in CKD stage 3, versus 32% in patients with normal renal function. Approximately 10% of UK patients have CKD in the general population. We estimated that LVH would mirror the degree of impaired exercise performance; therefore, to detect a similar difference in lower-than-normal predicted Embedded Image, a sample size ≥853 patients was required (α of 0.05; power of 80%). A 10% dropout rate was anticipated for patients in whom AT was difficult to assess, or who failed to complete CPET for medical reasons (arrhythmia, (pre-)syncope).


Clinical characteristics

We analysed CPET data for 933 patients (figure 1). CKD stage 3 was present in 93/933 (9.97%) patients. Demographics for patients are shown in table 1, stratified by the presence/absence of CKD stage 3. Patients were well matched for biochemical biomarkers synonymous with advanced CKD and increased risk of cardiovascular disease,30 namely, similar haemoglobin and albumin levels. Diabetes mellitus (RR 2.49 (95% CI 1.59 to 3.89); p<0.001), and hypertension (RR 3.20 (95% CI 2.04 to 5.03); p<0.001)) were more prevalent in CKD stage 3. However, clinically diagnosed/treated cardiac failure (RR 0.83 (95% CI 0.30 to 2.24); p=0.70) and ischaemic heart disease (RR 1.40 (95% CI 0.97 to 2.02); p=0.09) were not more prevalent in CKD3.

Table 1

Preoperative demographics/comorbidities for study population

Figure 1

Study analysis plan. CKD, chronic kidney disease; CPET, cardiopulmonary exercise testing; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; ITT, intention to treat.

Functional cardiovascular reserve in CKD3 versus normal renal function

Cardiopulmonary parameters measured during exercise are summarised in table 2. Consistent with their clinical cardiovascular phenotype, neither left ventricular stroke volume (predicted oxygen pulse; mean difference: 6% (−2 to 13); p=0.33) nor exercise-evoked ischaemia differed between patients with CKD3 and normal renal function. These data were consistent with a low prevalence of clinically diagnosed heart failure (<5% in both groups).

Table 2

CPET performance for study population

However, despite a similar prevalence of overt cardiovascular disease, CPET revealed that patients with CKD stage 3 had lower predicted values for AT and VO2peak, which control for age, gender, weight and height. Predicted VO2peak (mean difference: 6% (95% CI 1% to 11%); p=0.02) and lower AT (mean difference: 1.1 mL/min/kg (95% CI 0.4 to 1.7); p=0.002) were lower in patients with CKD stage 3. Ventilatory equivalents for carbon dioxide (Embedded Image), a powerful predictor of prognosis in clinically diagnosed heart failure, was substantially higher in patients with CKD stage 3 (mean difference: 3.5 (95% CI 2.4 to 4.6); p<0.001). Taken together, these data suggest that patients with CKD stage 3 have occult cardiovascular dysfunction that is not revealed by clinical history or routine tests.

Autonomic characteristics of CKD3

Online supplementary figure S1 summarises measures of heart rate dynamics made during CPET over time in patients with normal renal function and those with CKD stage 3. Similar resting heart rates were evident in patients with normal renal function and those with CKD stage 3. Table 3 summarises individualised changes in absolute heart rate indicative of sympathetic (peak and anticipatory) and parasympathetic (recovery) autonomic function. Patients with CKD stage 3 had lower peak heart rates attained during exercise (mean difference: 9 bpm (95% CI 3 to 14); p=0.002)) and impaired heart rate recovery (HRR; online supplementary figure S1) from peak exercise heart rate (mean difference: 4 bpm (95% CI 1 to 7); p=0.003)). Controlling for age, the smaller increases in peak heart rate from baseline (rise; figure 1), and lower heart rate recovery observed in patients with CKD stage 3 remained significant. Heart rate recovery in patients with CKD stage 3 was more likely to fall below 12 bpm (relative risk: 1.51 (95% CI 1.17 to 1.96); p<0.001), a threshold value which has been shown to be an independent predictor of all-cause and cardiovascular-related mortality.28 ,29 Anticipatory heart rate (AHRR; online supplementary figure S1) during unloaded pedalling, a measure of sympathetic dysfunction,31 was similar between groups.

Table 3

Dynamic heart rate changes during CPET

Functional cardiovascular reserve in CKD3 with/without essential hypertension

End-stage CKD is associated with lower exercise capacity compared to patients with hypertension.6 On subgroup analysis, we found that patients with CKD stage 3 without hypertension had lower exercise capacity compared to non-hypertensive patients with normal renal function (n=516; table 4). Similar results were obtained for patients with CKD stage 3 without diabetes mellitus (see online supplementary data). Multivariate analysis identified CKD stage 3 and pre-existing cardiac failure as independent predictors of VO2peak (table 5), taking into account coexistence of diabetes mellitus and hypertension.

Table 4

CPET characteristics of non-hypertensive patients with/without CKD stage 3

Table 5

Multivariate analysis of clinical predictors for peak VO2


These data show that CPET reveals subclinical differences in cardiopulmonary physiology in patients with CKD stage 3. Patients with CKD stage 3 did not have overt clinical histories or evidence for inferior cardiovascular performance. These data are the first to demonstrate that early CKD is associated with impaired cardiopulmonary reserve in the absence of known systolic heart failure. Importantly, our analyses used population norms for cardiopulmonary exercise performance controlling for age and gender, in contrast with a comparable study exploring the relationship between CKD and exercise capacity in patients with known systolic heart failure.10 Furthermore, these cardiopulmonary differences appear to precede established biomarkers for cardiovascular disease in more advanced CKD, including albumin and haemoglobin.30 These findings suggest that impaired exercise performance begins at a much earlier stage of CKD in keeping with cardiac structural insights provided by echocardiography.13 Although approximately half the patients studied had malignancy, this was not associated with the inferior exercise performance evident in CKD stage 3.

CKD increases the risk of acquiring32 ,33 and accelerates the progression of chronic heart failure.34–37 The pathophysiology of cardiorenal syndromes is a complex bidirectional process. Our findings provide functional physiological data using a gold standard assessment of cardiopulmonary functions that are consistent with previous morphological studies detailing subclinical cardiac abnormalities in CKD.13 Left ventricular hypertrophy is more common in patients with CKD, which has previously been thought to precede functional impairment.35 These structural differences appear to be driven by progressive CKD, in part, accounted for by the increased prevalence of diabetes mellitus and hypertension in CKD. Our data are consistent with recent epidemiological work showing that CKD confers greater risk of cardiovascular disease than diabetes,38 since patients with diabetes in this cohort free of CKD had superior cardiopulmonary exercise performance. Our data suggest that CKD has a further negative impact on poor cardiovascular function.

Because the prevalence of hypertension in patients with CKD is very common, we also compared patients free of, or with established, hypertension. In this large subset, we confirmed the overall findings that patients with CKD stage 3 without hypertension had lower exercise capacity compared to non-hypertensive controls. Furthermore, analysis of exercise-evoked changes in heart rate revealed distinct autonomic profiles in CKD stage 3. The finding that peak heart rate was impaired mirrors a similar observation in patients with end-stage CKD, in whom a blunted chronotropic response was an independent predictor of peak VO2.6 Furthermore, impaired parasympathetic dysfunction—as suggested by slower heart rate recovery in patients CKD—has emerged as an important contributor to myocardial injury,39 systemic inflammation40 and progression of CKD.41 ,42 Interestingly, patients with CKD stage 3 were more likely to have an HRR value previously shown to predict mortality and development of significant cardiovascular morbidity/mortality.28 ,29

Significant limitations include the observational cross-sectional nature of the study which prevents more robust conclusions regarding causality, particularly given limited information on the duration of key comorbid conditions including hypertension and diabetes. Echocardiographic correlates of exercise performance may provide further structural and functional insights, although static measures would not provide the depth of physiological insight afforded by CPET. Strengths of these data are reflected by the large data set, blinded study design, appropriately powered analysis plan, and established biological plausibility for the cardiovascular phenotypes described.

There are several clinical implications generated by these data. The presence of CKD stage 3 should alert clinicians to early CKD being a surrogate marker for poorer cardiac output under stress. CKD stage 3 is associated with poorer outcomes following major non-cardiac and cardiac surgery.43 Thus, acute blood loss, hypotension44 and/or hypovolemia in patients with CKD stage 3 may confer additional increased risk of pan-organ and further renal injury as a result of inferior cardiovascular performance. Further studies are required to determine whether the exercise phenotype maps to inferior cardiovascular performance in various clinical situations.

In summary, patients with CKD stage 3, but without clinical heart failure, have significantly worse cardiovascular function when challenged with standardised, protocolised physiological stress. In addition to the higher prevalence of diabetes mellitus and hypertension evident in patients with CKD stage 3, the subclinical dysfunctional cardiopulmonary phenotype described here provides additional pathophysiological mechanisms that may contribute to poorer clinical outcomes following acute cardiometabolic stress.

  • Received November 24, 2015.
  • Revision received January 9, 2016.
  • Accepted January 12, 2016.
View Abstract


  • Contributors GLA contributed to study design and data analysis. JW, AN and JMO contributed to data collection and data analysis. RS and DSM contributed to CPET data collection and data analysis. GLA and JP wrote the manuscript.

  • Funding This project was funded in part by a British Journal of Anaesthesia/Royal College of Anaesthetists John Snow Intercalated BSc award (AN); British Journal of Anaesthesia/Royal College of Anaesthetists Career Development Basic Science Fellowship award (GLA); National Institute for Health Research Central and East London Clinical Research Network. This work was undertaken at University College London Hospitals NHS Trust/University College London who received a proportion of funding from the Department of Health UK NIHR Biomedical Research Centre funding scheme.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Ethics approval MREC: 12/LO/0453.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

  • Data sharing statement Data is available on request to bone fide researchers from the corresponding author.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.